Audi S5: years to avoid
From CarsJudge AI assessments — real verdicts, not forum folklore.
2009-2012
High incidence of engine problems and timing chain issues
How the Audi S5 years we've judged score
| Year | Grade | Reliability |
|---|---|---|
| 2011 | C | 5.5/10 |
Common problems to check
- Oil consumption issues
- Timing chain tensioner failure
- Carbon buildup on intake valves
- Water pump leaks
Ownership reality
Typical annual maintenance: $1500 (CarsJudge AI assessment data).
Expected lifespan with proper care: 200,000 miles.
Judge any Audi S5 before you buy — freeSnap a photo or enter the VIN. 3 free AI assessments.
Full Audi S5 reviews by year
2011 Audi S5 review2013 Audi S5 review2018 Audi S5 review2019 Audi S5 review2020 Audi S5 review2021 Audi S5 review2022 Audi S5 review
Data: CarsJudge AI fleet assessments. Updated 2026-07-05.